Data study

Do insider trades predict earnings?

30,237 earnings releases at S&P 500 companies, 2010 to 2026, and the open-market trades of officers and directors before them.

  • When officers and directors trade their own stock, and why almost never right before earnings
  • Whether insider selling is a warning sign, and insider buying a promise
  • What the share price has already said by the time an insider trades, and the one thing it has not

PDF, 14 pages.

Front page of the StockFit data study "Do insider trades predict earnings?"

Foreword

Why we measured this

Insider trading has always attracted a lot of attention. When executives buy shares in their own company, investors often see it as a sign of confidence. When they sell, it's frequently interpreted as a warning.

And the reasoning makes sense. Officers and directors understand their businesses better than almost anyone on the outside. So you'd expect their trading activity to tell us something about the company's future performance.

But does the data actually support that assumption?

We decided to find out by looking at one of the most important recurring events for any publicly traded company: its quarterly earnings release.

We analyzed 30,237 earnings releases from S&P 500 companies between 2010 and 2026, matched them against open-market purchases and sales by officers and directors leading up to each release, and measured whether those trades provided any meaningful indication of the earnings results that followed.

Andy ReimannFounder, StockFit API

Inside the study

6 questions, answered with data

Each part of the study is built around one question. The answers, the charts and every number behind them are in the PDF.

A page of the study with a chart and a table, blurred
A page of the study with a chart, blurred
A page of the study with a chart, blurred
  1. 01

    When they trade

    When do officers and directors trade their own stock, and how close to an earnings release?

  2. 02

    How they trade

    After a release has moved the stock, do insiders buy or sell?

  3. 03

    Insider selling

    Is insider selling a warning sign for the quarter that is about to be reported?

  4. 04

    Insider buying

    Is insider buying a promise, and do the strongest purchase signals say more?

  5. 05

    The share price

    How much of what an insider trade says has the share price already said?

  6. 06

    The reception

    How does the stock react to the release after insiders have traded?

The data

What it is built on

earnings releases from 2010 to 2026
30,237
companies of the S&P 500
500
open-market purchases by officers and directors
15,775
open-market sales by officers and directors
183,961

Definitions

How the study counts

Which trades are counted?
Open-market purchases and sales by officers and directors, as reported on Form 4. Sales filed together with an option exercise by the same person, lines with fractional shares and filings replaced by an amendment are not counted.
What is an earnings release here?
The 8-K filing with which a company publishes its results (Item 2.02). The study covers the releases from January 2010 to September 2026.
Which trades belong to a release?
Every trade between the company's previous earnings release and this one. Windows of 60, 30, 15 and 5 days before the release were measured as well.
How is the outcome measured?
In two ways: whether the reported quarter's net income was higher than in the same quarter a year earlier, and the stock's return minus the return of the market after the release.
Which companies are in the study?
The 500 companies held by the S&P 500 index fund SPY in its holdings report of June 30, 2026, looked back to 2010.
Is this investment advice?
No. The study describes what happened in past filings and prices. It makes no forecast and recommends no trade.

Read the answers

Four parts, 14 pages, every chart built from SEC filings.

PDF, 14 pages.